Mistake Master

Membrane Permeability

The cell membrane is not a wall and it is not an open door — it is a filter. Its phospholipid bilayer has a hydrophobic core, an oily interior that welcomes some molecules and blocks others. Small, nonpolar molecules like O2 and CO2 slip straight through; small uncharged polar molecules like water squeeze across slowly; but large polar molecules and every ion are stopped cold at that oily middle. The membrane's structure decides who crosses, and that decision is the whole point of a selectively permeable boundary.

What gets shut out is not abandoned — it is handed to a protein. Glucose, amino acids, and ions cannot dissolve through the hydrophobic core, so the membrane studs itself with channel and carrier proteins that open a hydrophilic path across. This is why permeability is a property of the whole membrane, not of the lipid alone: a molecule the bilayer refuses may still cross freely wherever the right transport protein sits. Read a molecule's size, charge, and polarity against the membrane's structure and you can predict its fate — free passage, protein-assisted passage, or no passage at all.

Overview of Topic 2.5: the selectively permeable cell membrane sorting molecules by how they cross — small nonpolar gases passing freely through the phospholipid bilayer, ions and large polar molecules routed through channel and carrier proteins, and the hydrophobic core turning others away. Topic 2.5 infographicAdd bio2.5.svg to /bio/ to display
Interactive · Permeability Sorter

Sort each molecule by how it meets the membrane: free passage through the bilayer, protein-assisted passage through a channel or carrier, or no passage at all. Size, charge, and polarity on one side — the membrane's structure on the other.

Permeability Sorter · Open the full sandbox →

The common mistake here is treating the membrane as one uniform gate: assuming that if a molecule is small it must cross, or that anything the bilayer blocks is blocked from the cell entirely. Both readings ignore that selective permeability comes from two structures working together — the lipid core that turns molecules away and the transport proteins that let the turned-away ones through. Every scenario in this topic asks the same thing: say why a molecule can or cannot cross, tracing its fate to the membrane feature it actually meets, not to size alone.

The work

3 ways in · any order
Lesson
Membrane Permeability

The membrane's structure decides which molecules cross and how. The lesson walks the ways students collapse permeability into a single size rule and lose the two-part logic of the bilayer and its transport proteins, then closes with a ten-scenario applet: read each molecule against the membrane and say why it passes freely, needs a protein, or is shut out.

Skill check · 10 scenarios
Diagnostic
10-item topic check

Ten items on selective permeability, targeting three failure modes: assuming every molecule needs a transport protein, when small nonpolar ones cross the bilayer unaided (U2-BIO10), thinking the solute moves to even things out when the membrane blocks it and water is what actually crosses (U2-BIO14), and reading equilibrium as the moment motion stops rather than as balanced two-way traffic (U2-BIO2). Take it cold to surface which links are still broken, or after the lesson to confirm they hold.

Not started · 10 items · ~15 min
Targeted Practice
Drill a single misconception

Pick one of the failure modes you missed and drill it on its own. The round is adaptive: two correct in a row clears the misconception and moves you to the next.

Take the diagnostic to identify your misconceptions