Mistake Master

Volume with Disc Method: Revolving Around the x- or y-Axis AB & BC

Revolving a region makes every cross section a circle, so the disc method is 8.7's integral with $A = \pi r^{2}$: $V = \pi\int_a^b (f(x))^{2}\,dx$ about the $x$-axis, and $\pi\int_c^d (g(y))^{2}\,dy$ about the $y$-axis after solving the boundary for $x$ in terms of $y$. For $y = \sqrt{x}$ on $[0, 4]$ this gives $8\pi$. Dropping $\pi$ gives $8$, dropping the square gives $\frac{16\pi}{3}$, and squaring after integrating gives $\frac{256\pi}{9}$, since $\int f^{2}$ and $\left(\int f\right)^{2}$ are different quantities.

The radius is the distance from the axis of revolution to the curve, and $r = f(x)$ is the special case in which that axis is $y = 0$. Because a distance is squared, a region below the axis gives the same solid as its reflection. A disc assumes the slice has no hole, which holds exactly when the region touches the axis: the region under $y = \sqrt{x}$ does, while the region between $y = \sqrt{x}$ and $y = 1$ does not, and revolving the second one about the $x$-axis leaves a cylindrical hole that a disc integral would silently fill in.

REVOLVING THE REGION UNDER y = √x ABOUT THE x-AXIS. THE CURVE y = √x THE DASHED CURVE IS ITS MIRROR IMAGE, WHICH THE REVOLUTION SWEEPS OUT ONE SLICE IS A DISC OF RADIUS √x, SO ITS AREA IS πx AND V = 8π THE REGION TOUCHES THE AXIS, SO THERE IS NO HOLE THE MARKED RADIUS SITS AT x = 2.25, WHERE √x = 1.5.
Drawn to scale at $58$ px per unit horizontally and $40$ px per unit vertically, with the curve computed rather than sketched. The ellipse is the circular cross section seen in oblique projection; its true shape is a circle of radius $1.5$ standing perpendicular to the page.
FOUR SETUPS FOR y = √x ON [0, 4] ABOUT THE x-AXIS. WHAT IS WRITTEN VALUE WHAT WENT WRONG π ∫ (√x)² dx NOTHING ∫ (√x)² dx 8 NO π π ∫ √x dx 16π/3 NO SQUARE π (∫ √x dx)² 256π/9 SQUARED TOO LATE THE LAST ROW IS NOT BOOKKEEPING. EACH SLICE HAS ITS OWN RADIUS, AND ADDING AREAS IS NOT SQUARING A SUM OF RADII.
All four rows use the same curve and the same interval. The three wrong values, $8$, $\frac{16\pi}{3}$ and $\frac{256\pi}{9}$, are far enough apart that an answer identifies which step was skipped.

The work

3 ways in · any order
Lesson
Volume with Disc Method: Revolving Around the x- or y-Axis

Presents the disc method as the cross-section integral with a circular slice, keeps pi and the square inside the integral, identifies the radius as a distance from the axis of revolution rather than as the function itself, and establishes the touching-the-axis condition that decides whether a disc was legal at all.

Skill check · 10 scenarios
Diagnostic
10-item topic check

Ten items on the disc method about the axes: placing pi and the square correctly, distinguishing the integral of a square from the square of an integral, converting to dy for revolutions about the y-axis, and recognising when the region leaves a hole.

Not yet available · 10 items
Targeted Practice
Drill a single misconception

Pick one of the failure modes you missed and drill it on its own. The round is adaptive: two correct in a row clears the misconception and moves you to the next.

Take the diagnostic to identify your misconceptions