Mistake Master

The Arc Length of a Smooth, Planar Curve and Distance Traveled BC only

A short piece of curve has horizontal extent $dx$ and vertical extent $dy$, so $ds = \sqrt{(dx)^{2} + (dy)^{2}}$, and factoring $dx$ out gives $L = \int_a^b \sqrt{1 + (f'(x))^{2}}\,dx$. The $1$ is the factored $(dx)^{2}$, the square comes from the Pythagorean theorem, and the root is the theorem itself, so a formula rebuilt from the triangle keeps all three. For $y = x^{3/2}$ on $[0, 5]$ the true length is $\frac{335}{27} \approx 12.407$, while dropping the $1$ gives $11.180$ and dropping the root gives $33.125$. Substituting $f$ for $f'$ measures nothing: length depends on steepness, not height.

Two checks cost nothing. On the straight line $y = 3x$ over $[0, 4]$ the formula must reproduce the distance formula, and both give $4\sqrt{10}$. And an arc length is at least the horizontal extent and at least the straight-line distance between the endpoints, which rules out $11.180$ immediately, since it falls below the chord length $\sqrt{150}$. For a curve described as $x = g(y)$ the integrand is $\sqrt{1 + (g'(y))^{2}}$ with $y$-limits, and for a parametric path it is $\sqrt{(x')^{2} + (y')^{2}}\,dt$, which has no $1$ because the $1$ was $\left(\frac{dx}{dx}\right)^{2}$ all along. That parametric integral is distance travelled, not displacement: it counts ground covered twice by a path that doubles back.

A SHORT PIECE OF CURVE IS ESSENTIALLY A STRAIGHT SEGMENT. dx dy ds THE SAME TRIANGLE, MAGNIFIED ds² = dx² + dy², SO ds = √(dx² + dy²). FACTOR dx OUT OF THE ROOT: ds = √(1 + (dy/dx)²) dx. THE 1 IS THE dx² THAT CAME OUT. IT IS NOT DECORATION.
The left panel is drawn to scale at $30$ px per unit horizontally and $25$ px per unit vertically, with the curve computed rather than sketched. The small triangle spans one unit of $x$; the magnified copy on the right has legs in the ratio $4$ to $3$, so its hypotenuse is exactly $\frac{5}{4}$ of its horizontal leg.
FOR y = x^(3/2) ON [0, 5]. THE CHORD FROM END TO END IS 12.247. THE INTEGRAND VALUE WHAT IS MISSING √(1 + (f′)²) 12.407 NOTHING √((f′)²) 11.180 THE 1 1 + (f′)² 33.125 THE ROOT √(1 + f′) NOT A LENGTH THE SQUARE √(1 + f²) NOT A LENGTH f′ ITSELF ROW TWO FALLS BELOW THE CHORD, SO IT IS WRONG WITHOUT CHECKING.
The second row is the useful one to remember, because it fails a test that needs no calculus: an arc length cannot be shorter than the straight line joining its endpoints, and $11.180$ is less than $12.247$.

The work

3 ways in · any order
Lesson
The Arc Length of a Smooth, Planar Curve and Distance Traveled

Derives the arc length integrand from a Pythagorean triangle on a short piece of curve so that the added 1, the squared derivative and the square root each have a source, checks the formula against the distance formula on a line, bounds an arc length below by its chord, and extends the same triangle to parametric distance travelled.

Skill check · 10 scenarios
Diagnostic
10-item topic check

Ten items on arc length: keeping all three parts of the integrand, using the derivative rather than the function, integrating with respect to the right variable over the right interval, and separating distance travelled from displacement on a parametric path.

Not yet available · 10 items
Targeted Practice
Drill a single misconception

Pick one of the failure modes you missed and drill it on its own. The round is adaptive: two correct in a row clears the misconception and moves you to the next.

Take the diagnostic to identify your misconceptions