Mistake Master

Volume with Washer Method: Revolving Around the x- or y-Axis AB & BC

A washer is a disc with a smaller disc removed, so its area is $\pi(R^{2} - r^{2})$ and the volume is $\pi\int_a^b (R^{2} - r^{2})\,dx$, with $R$ the distance from the axis to the far boundary and $r$ the distance to the near one. That expression is two disc integrals subtracted, and it is never $\pi(R - r)^{2}$: for $R = 5$ and $r = 3$ the two give $16\pi$ and $4\pi$. $R - r$ is the width of the ring, and a thin ring at a large radius has far more area than a small disc, because it is stretched around a long circumference.

The outer radius reaches whichever boundary is farther from the axis, decided by testing a point inside the interval rather than read off the equations. For $y = 2x$ and $y = x^{2}$ on $[0, 2]$ about the $x$-axis, $R = 2x$ and $r = x^{2}$ give $\frac{64\pi}{15}$; dropping the inner radius gives $\frac{32\pi}{3}$ and squaring the difference gives $\frac{16\pi}{15}$. A region that touches the axis has $r = 0$ there and needs a disc, a region that stops short needs a washer, and a region that does both needs a split. About the $y$-axis both boundaries must be solved for $x$, so the conversion has two chances to fail rather than one.

THE REGION, AND ONE WASHER IT SWEEPS OUT. ONE SLICE IS A RING OUTER RADIUS R = 2x INNER RADIUS r = x² AREA = π(R² − r²) NOT π(R − r)² V = 64π/15 THE HOLE IS THE DISC SWEPT BY THE PARABOLA. IT IS REMOVED BY SUBTRACTING ITS AREA, NOT BY SHORTENING THE OUTER RADIUS.
The left panel is drawn to scale at $90$ px per unit horizontally and $45$ px per unit vertically, with the parabola computed rather than sketched. The right panel is one cross section in oblique projection; the two ellipses are concentric because both radii are measured from the same axis.
THE TWO EXPRESSIONS AGREE ONLY WHEN THE HOLE HAS NO SIZE. R r R² − r² (R − r)² 5 3 16 4 5 4 9 1 5 1 24 16 5 0 25 25 R − r IS THE WIDTH OF THE RING. A NARROW RING AT A LARGE RADIUS HOLDS FAR MORE AREA THAN A SMALL DISC OF THAT WIDTH, BECAUSE IT IS WRAPPED AROUND A LONG CIRCUMFERENCE.
The last row is the only agreement, and it is the case $r = 0$, where the washer is a disc. Everywhere else the square of the difference understates the ring, and the gap grows as the hole grows.

The work

3 ways in · any order
Lesson
Volume with Washer Method: Revolving Around the x- or y-Axis

Builds the washer as one disc integral minus another, separates the difference of squared radii from the square of the difference with numbers rather than algebra, assigns the outer radius by testing a point, and settles when a region needs a washer, a disc, or a split between the two.

Skill check · 10 scenarios
Diagnostic
10-item topic check

Ten items on the washer method about the axes: subtracting squared radii rather than radii, identifying the outer and inner boundaries, recognising when the region leaves a hole, and keeping pi across the whole integrand.

Not yet available · 10 items
Targeted Practice
Drill a single misconception

Pick one of the failure modes you missed and drill it on its own. The round is adaptive: two correct in a row clears the misconception and moves you to the next.

Take the diagnostic to identify your misconceptions