Mistake Master

Volumes with Cross Sections: Triangles and Semicircles AB & BC

Only the constant changes from 8.7. An equilateral triangle of side $s$ has height $\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}s$ and area $\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}s^{2}$, so keeping the height as the area doubles the answer. An isosceles right triangle has area $\frac{1}{2}s^{2}$ when the base is a leg and $\frac{s^{2}}{4}$ when the base is the hypotenuse, since the altitude to a hypotenuse of length $s$ is $\frac{s}{2}$. The phrase in the problem is what separates the two, and the factor between them is $2$.

A semicircle standing on a base has that base as its diameter, so $r = \frac{s}{2}$ and $A = \frac{1}{2}\pi r^{2} = \frac{\pi}{8}s^{2}$; using $s$ as the radius is four times too large, and forgetting to halve the circle is twice too large. Writing $r = \frac{s}{2}$ on its own line before substituting prevents both. Over the base under $y = \sqrt{x}$ on $[0, 4]$, where $s^{2} = x$ and $\int_0^4 x\,dx = 8$, the three volumes are $2\sqrt{3}$, $4$ and $\pi$, and the right triangle's solid being the largest and the semicircle's the smallest is a check on the constants.

THREE CROSS SECTIONS ON THE SAME BASE SEGMENT OF LENGTH s. s s s EQUILATERAL (√3/4)s² RIGHT, LEG s s²/2 SEMICIRCLE (π/8)s² HEIGHT 0.866s HEIGHT s HEIGHT s/2 THE TALLEST SHAPE MAKES THE LARGEST SOLID, AND THE SEMICIRCLE IS THE SHORTEST OF THE THREE.
All three sit on a base of $120$ px, drawn to scale, so the heights shown are the true $0.866s$, $s$ and $\frac{s}{2}$. On a single base region those proportions force the volumes into the same order, which is a check worth running on any answer.
WHAT THE BASE IS TO THE SHAPE DECIDES THE CONSTANT. THE BASE s IS THE ... SO THE HEIGHT IS AREA SIDE OF AN EQUILATERAL △ (√3/2)s (√3/4)s² LEG OF A RIGHT ISOSCELES △ s s²/2 HYPOTENUSE OF THAT △ s/2 s²/4 DIAMETER OF A SEMICIRCLE s/2 (π/8)s² RADIUS OF A QUARTER CIRCLE s (π/4)s² ROWS TWO AND THREE ARE THE SAME TRIANGLE, DESCRIBED TWICE.
The middle column is the step that gets skipped. Writing the height down before the area keeps $\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}$ from being reported as the area constant and keeps a diameter from being used as a radius.

The work

3 ways in · any order
Lesson
Volumes with Cross Sections: Triangles and Semicircles

Derives each cross-sectional constant rather than asserting it: the equilateral triangle's height and the halving that follows, the isosceles right triangle on a leg against on a hypotenuse, and the semicircle whose base is a diameter and whose formula wants a radius. Ends by ordering the three solids on one base as a check.

Skill check · 10 scenarios
Diagnostic
10-item topic check

Ten items on triangular and semicircular cross sections: applying the correct area constant, telling a leg from a hypotenuse and a diameter from a radius, and finding the base length between two curves before any constant is applied.

Not yet available · 10 items
Targeted Practice
Drill a single misconception

Pick one of the failure modes you missed and drill it on its own. The round is adaptive: two correct in a row clears the misconception and moves you to the next.

Take the diagnostic to identify your misconceptions