Mistake Master

Modeling Situations with Differential Equations AB & BC

Modeling means turning a sentence about a rate into an equation with a derivative in it, and nothing here is solved. The phrase that follows "proportional to" is exactly what the constant $k$ multiplies: proportional to $y$ gives $\frac{dy}{dt} = ky$, proportional to the difference between $T$ and $70$ gives $\frac{dT}{dt} = k(T - 70)$ with the parentheses carrying the whole meaning, inversely proportional to $y$ gives $\frac{dy}{dt} = \frac{k}{y}$, and proportional to a product gives $\frac{dy}{dt} = ky(M - y)$.

The constant decides direction: $k > 0$ grows and $k < 0$ decays, so a decay model with a positive $k$ describes the opposite process. $k$ is not the starting amount, not a count per unit time, and not the doubling time; its units are a reciprocal time, so $k = 0.05$ per year means five percent of the current size per year. A finished model can be read without solving: in $\frac{dy}{dt} = 0.3(200 - y)$ the rate is positive below $200$, negative above it, and zero at the equilibrium solution $y = 200$, which every solution approaches and slows down near.

THE SENTENCE SAYS THE EQUATION SAYS PROPORTIONAL TO ITS SIZE dP/dt = kP PROPORTIONAL TO T − 70 dT/dt = k(T − 70) INVERSELY PROPORTIONAL TO y dy/dt = k/y PROPORTIONAL TO √h dh/dt = k√h PROPORTIONAL TO y TIMES M − y dy/dt = ky(M − y) PROPORTIONAL TO THE TIME t dy/dt = kt EVERY ROW ON THE LEFT DESCRIBES A RATE, SO EVERY RIGHT SIDE IS A DERIVATIVE. WHATEVER FOLLOWS PROPORTIONAL TO IS WHAT k MULTIPLIES, PARENTHESES INCLUDED. THE LAST ROW IS THE COMMON MISTRANSLATION OF THE FIRST: t IS NOT THE AMOUNT.
The last row is dimmed because it is the trap, not a model anyone asked for: "proportional to its size" is about $y$, and "proportional to the time" is about $t$. Only one of those appears in the sentence.
dT/dt = k(T − 70), WITH k NEGATIVE. THE ROOM SITS AT 70°. COFFEE AT 190° FALLING, AND FLATTENING SODA AT 40° ROOM: 70° 190 130 70 40 0 10 20 30 THE RATE FOLLOWS T − 70, SO IT SHRINKS AS EITHER CURVE NEARS 70°. ONE MODEL, ONE k, TWO DIRECTIONS. THE STARTING VALUE PICKS THE SIDE.
Drawn to scale at $13.3$ px per minute across and $1$ px per degree up, with $k = -0.09$ per minute. Both curves obey the same equation; the sign of $T - 70$ at the start is the only thing that differs.

The work

3 ways in · any order
Lesson
Modeling Situations with Differential Equations

Turns rate language into a derivative and shows exactly what the constant of proportionality multiplies, through direct, inverse, square-root and product forms, then reads the sign and the units of that constant back out and identifies the equilibrium of a finished model without solving it.

Skill check · 10 scenarios
Diagnostic
10-item topic check

Ten items on the two failure modes of modeling: writing an equation about the quantity instead of its rate or attaching k to the wrong expression, and misreading what the constant means once the model is written.

Not yet available · 10 items
Targeted Practice
Drill a single misconception

Pick one of the failure modes you missed and drill it on its own. The round is adaptive: two correct in a row clears the misconception and moves you to the next.

Take the diagnostic to identify your misconceptions