Mistake Master
Student view — seeing the site as a student does
CED objectives

Introduction to Optimization Problems AB & BC

▶︎  Watch it animatedinteractive step-through · ~3 min · optional

An optimization problem carries an objective, the quantity to be made largest or smallest, and a constraint, the relationship that limits the choices. The question decides which is which. For a rectangular plot with 1200 feet of fence on three sides, the objective is $A = xy$ and the constraint is $2x + y = 1200$; solving the constraint for $y$ and substituting gives $A(x) = x(1200 - 2x)$, a single function of a single variable that the rest of the unit can handle.

Two habits break the setup. The constraint goes unused, and $A = xy$ is differentiated with $y$ treated as a constant, which asserts that lengthening one side leaves the other alone. And the domain is taken from the algebra rather than from the situation: $V(x) = x(12 - 2x)^{2}$ is a polynomial defined everywhere and describes a real box only for $0 < x < 6$. Positivity, stated caps, whole-number counts, and the point where a formula stops applying are all part of the domain. When the objective is a distance, minimize its square, since both are smallest at the same input.

1200 FEET OF FENCE ON THREE SIDES OF A RECTANGLE. MAXIMIZE THE AREA. RIVER (NO FENCE) x x y THE SETUP, IN FOUR LINES OBJECTIVE: A = xy CONSTRAINT: 2x + y = 1200 REDUCE: y = 1200 − 2x ONE VARIABLE: A(x) = x(1200 − 2x) DOMAIN: 0 < x < 600 A(x) = x(1200 − 2x) HAS ONE VARIABLE AND A STATED DOMAIN. UNTIL BOTH ARE TRUE, THERE IS NOTHING TO DIFFERENTIATE.
Two sides are $x$ and one is $y$, because the river takes the fourth. The constraint is what makes the problem answerable at all.
A 12 BY 12 SHEET, SQUARES OF SIDE x CUT FROM THE CORNERS, SIDES FOLDED UP. 12 x 12 − 2x V(x) = x(12 − 2x)² WHY 0 < x < 6: x ≤ 0 GIVES NO BOX x ≥ 6 REMOVES THE WHOLE WIDTH: 12 − 2x ≤ 0 V = 0 AT BOTH ENDS, SO THE MAXIMUM IS INTERIOR. THE PHYSICAL SITUATION SUPPLIES THE DOMAIN. WITHOUT IT, x = 8 LOOKS LEGAL.
Drawn to scale at 15 px per unit, with the corner cuts at $x = 2$. Substituting $x = 8$ returns $128$, which describes a box that cannot be built.

The work

3 ways in · any order
Lesson
Introduction to Optimization Problems

Separates the objective from the constraint and shows why the question rather than the algebra decides which is which, reduces two-variable objectives to one variable on the fence, box, and can problems, derives each domain from the physical situation, and adds the move that makes distance problems tractable.

Skill check · 10 scenarios
Diagnostic
10-item topic check

Ten items spanning the two failure modes of this topic: differentiating an objective in two variables without using the constraint to eliminate one, and optimizing over all real numbers while ignoring the restrictions and endpoints the context imposes.

Not started · 10 items · ~15 min
Targeted Practice
Drill a single misconception

Pick one of the failure modes you missed and drill it on its own. The round is adaptive: two correct in a row clears it for now and moves you to the next. Two in a row is a checkpoint, not proof: if the error resurfaces later, the misconception comes back.

Take the diagnostic to identify your misconceptions