Mistake Master
Home Unit 1 · Atomic Structure & Properties 1.1·1.2·1.3·1.4·1.5·1.6·1.7·1.8 Lesson
Skill Check 0 / 10 complete

Composition of mixtures

A compound has one fixed recipe; a mixture does not. Two samples of the same mixture can have different proportions and still be the same mixture. Half the mistakes in this topic come from applying compound rules to blends.

§1

Pure substances have one recipe; mixtures don't.

A pure substance — an element or a compound — is built from a single kind of particle, so its composition is fixed. Water is always two hydrogens to one oxygen; no sample of pure water is ever 20% hydrogen. Its percent composition is a fingerprint.

A mixture contains more than one kind of particle, physically combined, and its proportions can vary from sample to sample. Salt water can be barely salty or nearly saturated and still be salt water. That is the defining difference: a mixture's composition is not fixed, and the components keep their own identities and can be separated by physical means.

Because a mixture's composition varies, you cannot look it up — you have to measure it. The usual route is to separate the components physically, weigh them, and compare each mass to the total. Since separation neither creates nor destroys matter, the component masses always add back to the starting mass.

UNIT 1 TOPIC 1.4 • COMPOSITION OF MIXTURES PURE vs MIXTURE PURE SUBSTANCE — FIXED water, H₂O — every sample identical 11% H 89% O Always 11% / 89% by mass. Composition never changes. MIXTURE — VARIES salt + sand — any proportion 40% salt 70% salt Same two ingredients, different composition each time. FINDING A MIXTURE'S COMPOSITION BY SEPARATION 10.0 g mixture = 4.0 g salt 40% by mass + 6.0 g sand 60% by mass MASS IS CONSERVED: the parts add back to the whole. 4.0 g + 6.0 g = 10.0 g. Mass percent salt = 4.0 ÷ 10.0 × 100 = 40%. AP Chemistry · Unit 1 · Atomic Structure & Properties
Fig. 1.4.1 A pure substance has one fixed composition; a mixture of the same ingredients can take any proportion. To measure a mixture's composition, physically separate the components and weigh them — the masses add back to the total, and each component's mass over the total gives its mass percent.
§2

Measuring what's in a mixture.

Composition problems for mixtures come down to bookkeeping with conserved mass. The steps rarely change.

  1. Separate by a physical property. Dissolving, filtering, evaporating, or magnetism splits the mixture without changing what each component is. Salt dissolves and sand does not, so filtering divides them.
  2. Weigh each recovered component. The masses you recover must sum to the mass you started with. If they don't, you lost some material, not made or destroyed any.
  3. Divide each part by the whole. Mass percent of a component = (mass of that component ÷ total mass) × 100. The percentages of all components add to 100%.
  4. Use a component's back to grams when needed. Given a percent and a total mass, multiply to recover a component's mass: 40% of 10.0 g is 4.0 g. The percent is a ratio; the grams depend on how much you took.

A useful shortcut: if a mixture has only two components, finding one immediately gives the other. Recover 6.0 g of sand from a 10.0 g mixture and the salt must be 4.0 g — no separate measurement needed.

§3

The pieces you'll meet.

Quick reference card. Sort what has fixed composition from what does not.

pure
Pure substance
One kind of particle. Element or compound. Fixed composition, separated only by chemical change.
mix
Mixture
Multiple particle types, physically combined. Variable composition, separated by physical means.
mass %
Component mass percent
(component mass ÷ total mass) × 100. For a mixture, not a fixed value.
Σm
Mass conservation
Recovered parts sum to the starting mass. Separation moves matter, never destroys it.
marker
Unique-element trick
An element in only one component lets you trace that component's amount specifically.
2-part
Two-component shortcut
With two components, finding one gives the other by subtraction from the total.
§4

Worked example: separating salt from sand.

Question. A 10.0 g mixture of table salt and sand is stirred into water, filtered, and the filtrate evaporated. You recover 4.0 g of salt. What is the mixture's composition by mass?

Step 1 — separate. Salt dissolves; sand does not. Filtering keeps the sand on the paper and the salt in solution — a physical separation that changes neither substance.

Step 2 — weigh and check conservation. Evaporating the filtrate leaves 4.0 g of salt. By mass conservation, the sand is 10.0 − 4.0 = 6.0 g.

Step 3 — divide each part by the whole. Salt: 4.0 ÷ 10.0 × 100 = 40% salt. Sand: 6.0 ÷ 10.0 × 100 = 60% sand. They add to 100%, as they must.

Sanity check. A different scoop of the same salt-and-sand pile could easily be 25% salt or 55% salt — the 40% is a property of this sample, not of "salt-and-sand mixtures" in general. That variability is exactly what makes it a mixture rather than a compound.

§5

3 mistakes that cost real points.

Pitfall · 01

"A mixture has a fixed percent composition too."

Only pure substances do. Every sample of pure carbon dioxide is 27% carbon by mass, always. But a bag of trail mix, a beaker of salt water, or a scoop of salt-and-sand can be almost any proportion. Quoting "the" composition of a mixture as if it were a constant is a category error.

Fix. Ask first: pure substance or mixture? If it is a mixture, its composition is a measured property of that sample, not a lookup value.

Pitfall · 02

"Separating the mixture changed the total mass."

Physical separation just relocates matter. If a 10.0 g mixture yields 4.0 g of one component, the rest — 6.0 g — is the other component, not lost. A recovered total below the start means material was spilled or left behind, not that mass vanished.

Fix. Make the masses balance: components must sum to the starting mass. Use that equation to find a component you didn't measure directly.

Pitfall · 03

"A compound is the same thing as a mixture of its elements."

Water is not a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen — it is a compound, with the two elements chemically bonded in a fixed 2:1 ratio and properties nothing like either gas. A mixture of hydrogen and oxygen gas, by contrast, keeps both gases intact in any ratio. Chemical bonding, and fixed versus variable composition, separate the two ideas.

Fix. A compound is one pure substance with a fixed formula; a mixture is several substances kept side by side. Bonded and fixed means compound; combined and variable means mixture.

§6

Skill Check.

Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.

0 of 10 scenarios complete