Mistake Master
Parametric rates of change
A moving point has two coordinates, so it has two rates of change, one per component, each taken with respect to the parameter. Almost everything in this topic is bookkeeping those two rates honestly: computing each on its own, combining them into a slope only by division, and never letting one component answer for the other.
§1
One rate per component.
▸
Over an interval of parameter values, each coordinate function has its own average rate of change: change in that coordinate divided by change in t. If a particle is at (3, 2) when t = 1 and at (7, 10) when t = 3, then over that interval
- x changes at $(7-3)/(3-1) = 2$ units per unit of t, and
- y changes at $(10-2)/(3-1) = 4$ units per unit of t.
Two rates, computed separately, never averaged together. The x-rate says how fast the particle drifts horizontally; the y-rate how fast it climbs. Signs carry direction: a negative x-rate is net leftward drift, a negative y-rate net downward.
§2
Slope along the path: the ratio of the changes.
▸
The slope of the secant between two positions on the path is rise over run in the plane: $\Delta y / \Delta x$. Using the same two positions, slope $= (10-2)/(7-3) = 2$. Notice the parameter has vanished: both changes happened over the same t interval, so the t's cancel, and the slope is also the ratio of the two component rates, $4/2 = 2$.
That gives two equivalent recipes and one warning. Recipes: divide the coordinate changes directly, or divide the y-rate by the x-rate. Warning: the y-rate alone is NOT the slope. A y-rate of 4 with an x-rate of 2 gives slope 2; the same y-rate with an x-rate of 8 gives slope 1/2. Slope always needs both components.
§3
Signs tell the direction; the ratio can deceive.
▸
Read the two signs first, the ratio second. A particle moving left and up has $\Delta x < 0$ and $\Delta y > 0$, so its secant slope is negative, even though the particle is rising. A negative slope on a parametric path does not mean "going down"; it means the two components disagree in sign, and which one is negative matters. Rising-while-moving-left and falling-while-moving-right both produce negative slopes from opposite motions.
This is the sharpest difference from y = f(x) graphs, where x always increases and slope alone tells the vertical story. On a path, direction is two independent signs; the slope is only their quotient.
§4
Who is changing faster?
▸
Comparing the two rates in size predicts the path's local character. When $|\Delta x|$ dwarfs $|\Delta y|$, travel is nearly horizontal and the slope is near 0. When $|\Delta y|$ dwarfs $|\Delta x|$, travel is nearly vertical and the slope is large; in the limit of a zero x-change the secant is vertical and the slope is undefined, which a parametric path handles without complaint.
And remember these are average rates over the interval: an x-rate of zero across [2, 5] means the particle ended at the horizontal position where it started, not that it never moved horizontally in between. The interval's interior is invisible to an average computed from endpoints.
§5
Skill Check.
▸
Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.