Mistake Master
Student view — seeing the site as a student does
Home Unit 12 · Magnetism and Electromagnetism 12.1·12.2·12.3·12.4 Lesson
Skill Check 0 / 10 complete

A force that only turns

Three properties of $F = qvB\sin\theta$ do most of the work, and each one contradicts a habit brought over from electric fields. It needs motion, and specifically motion with a component perpendicular to $\vec{B}$. Its direction is perpendicular to both $\vec{v}$ and $\vec{B}$, so it points along neither. And because it is always perpendicular to the velocity, it does no work: it turns the particle without ever changing its speed.

§1

No motion across the field, no force.

$$F = qvB\sin\theta, \qquad \theta \ \text{between} \ \vec{v} \ \text{and} \ \vec{B}.$$

Two cases give exactly zero, and both are worth checking before anything else:

  1. The charge is at rest. $v = 0$, so $F = 0$, in the strongest field you can build.
  2. The charge moves along the field lines. $\theta = 0$, $\sin 0 = 0$, so $F = 0$ however fast it goes.

Only the component of $\vec{v}$ perpendicular to $\vec{B}$ produces a force. That is a real difference from the electric case, where $\vec{F} = q\vec{E}$ acts whether or not the charge moves, and it is why one field can steer a beam hard while another leaves it alone.

The symmetry runs the other way too: a stationary charge produces no magnetic field of its own. Magnetism is what electricity looks like when charge is moving.

§2

The force is perpendicular to both inputs.

Set up the right-hand rule with the fingers along $\vec{v}$, curling toward $\vec{B}$; the thumb gives the force on a positive charge. The result is perpendicular to the plane that $\vec{v}$ and $\vec{B}$ share.

So an answer with the force arrow parallel to $\vec{B}$ is wrong by construction, and so is one parallel to $\vec{v}$. Both mistakes produce a particle that speeds up or reverses, and the sideways deflection that actually happens never appears.

Then the step that is easiest to lose: for a negative charge, reverse the result. The hand motion feels like the whole procedure, so the sign gets dropped. Say it out loud as its own step. The check is that a proton and an electron sent along the same path through the same field bend to opposite sides.

§3

Zero work, so the speed cannot change.

A force perpendicular to the velocity does no work, so the magnetic force on a moving charge changes the direction of $\vec{v}$ and never its magnitude. A particle enters a field region at $2\times10^6$ m/s and leaves at exactly $2\times10^6$ m/s.

A stronger field tightens the curve and still adds no energy, which is why a particle can circle in a uniform field indefinitely at one speed. Watching the velocity vector turn and calling that "acceleration" in the everyday sense is what produces the wrong answer; acceleration here means a change of direction.

So if a problem's kinetic energy does change, the energy came from somewhere else: an electric field, or an induced emf. The magnetic force on a moving charge can never supply it.

§4

The radius grows with speed.

For a charge moving perpendicular to a uniform field, the magnetic force supplies exactly the centripetal force:

$$qvB = \frac{mv^2}{r} \qquad \Longrightarrow \qquad r = \frac{mv}{qB}.$$

Read every factor off the solved expression rather than arguing from the force. Twice the speed needs twice the radius; twice the mass, twice the radius; twice the charge or twice the field, half the radius.

"A faster particle feels a bigger force, so it gets held in tighter" is the trap, and the resolution is in the two powers of $v$. The magnetic force grows as $v$, and the centripetal force required grows as $v^2$. The requirement outruns the supply, so the circle has to open up.

One tidy consequence: the period $T = 2\pi m/(qB)$ contains no $v$ at all. Faster particles travel bigger circles in exactly the same time.

§5

Skill Check.

Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.

0 of 10 scenarios complete