Mistake Master
Le Chatelier's principle
Push on a system at equilibrium and it pushes back. Le Chatelier's principle predicts which way — but you have to know which stresses move the position and which actually change K.
§1
Systems that push back.
▸
Le Chatelier's principle: a system at equilibrium responds to a stress by shifting to partly counteract it. Add a reactant and it shifts toward products; remove a product and it shifts toward products; add a product and it shifts back toward reactants.
Changing volume (pressure) shifts a gaseous equilibrium toward the side with fewer moles of gas when the volume is decreased. But a concentration or volume stress shifts the position without changing K itself.
Two things do not shift the equilibrium as students expect: a catalyst (it speeds both directions equally, reaching the same position faster), and, for K, any concentration change. Only temperature changes K.
§2
Predicting a shift.
▸
Name the stress, then the counteracting shift.
- Identify the stress. Added/removed species, changed volume/pressure, or changed temperature.
- Shift to counteract it. Add reactant → shift right; remove product → shift right; decrease volume → shift toward fewer gas moles.
- Decide whether K changes. Concentration and volume changes shift the position but leave K unchanged; only temperature changes K.
- Remember catalysts. A catalyst does not shift the equilibrium; it just reaches it faster.
§3
The pieces you'll meet.
▸
Stress in, counteracting shift out.
§4
Worked example: apply the principle.
▸
Stress 1 — add reactant. Adding more A to A + B ⇌ C shifts the equilibrium right to consume the added A. K is unchanged.
Stress 2 — decrease volume. For a gaseous reaction, compressing the system shifts toward the side with fewer gas moles. K is unchanged.
Stress 3 — add a catalyst. No shift — the catalyst speeds both directions equally, so the same equilibrium position is reached faster.
Stress 4 — change temperature. This is the special case: it actually changes K, shifting the equilibrium to a genuinely new position.
§5
Mistakes that cost real points.
▸
"A catalyst shifts the equilibrium toward products."
A catalyst speeds the forward and reverse reactions equally, so it reaches the same equilibrium position faster but does not shift it. The equilibrium amounts are identical with or without a catalyst.
Fix. Treat a catalyst as changing only the speed to equilibrium, never the position or the amounts.
"Adding more reactant (a concentration stress) changes K."
A concentration change shifts the position of equilibrium but does not change K. The system shifts so that Q returns to the unchanged K. Only a temperature change alters K itself.
Fix. Distinguish position from K: concentration and volume stresses shift the position; only temperature changes K.
"Decreasing the volume shifts a gas equilibrium toward more moles of gas."
Decreasing the volume (raising pressure) shifts toward the side with fewer moles of gas, to reduce the pressure — the opposite direction. Shifting toward more moles would worsen the stress.
Fix. Compress → shift toward fewer gas moles; expand → shift toward more gas moles.
§6
Skill Check.
▸
Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.