Mistake Master
Direction of reversible reactions
A reversible reaction does not have a fixed direction — it depends on where you start. Compare the reaction quotient Q to the equilibrium constant K and the arrow points itself.
§1
Q versus K sets the direction.
▸
A reversible reaction can run either way, and the direction it will go depends on the current mixture. Compute the reaction quotient Q from the current concentrations and compare it to the equilibrium constant K.
If Q < K, there is too little product relative to equilibrium, so the reaction shifts right (toward products). If Q > K, there is too much product, so it shifts left (toward reactants).
If Q = K, the system is already at equilibrium and does not shift. Q is the moving indicator that tells the system which way to go to reach the fixed target K.
§2
Predicting the shift.
▸
Build Q, compare to K, read the arrow.
- Compute Q from current values. Use the same expression as K, with the current (non-equilibrium) concentrations.
- Compare Q to K. Is Q less than, greater than, or equal to K?
- Read the direction. Q < K shifts right; Q > K shifts left; Q = K is at equilibrium.
- Remember reactions go both ways. A reversible reaction can run forward or backward depending on the starting mixture.
§3
The pieces you'll meet.
▸
Q is the indicator; K is the target.
§4
Worked example: which way does it go?
▸
Given. A reaction has K = 10. In the current mixture, the quotient works out to Q = 2.
Compare. Q (2) is less than K (10).
Direction. Q < K, so the reaction shifts right, toward products, raising Q until it reaches K.
Contrast. If instead Q had been 50 (> K), the reaction would shift left toward reactants. Same reaction, opposite direction — set by Q versus K.
§5
Mistakes that cost real points.
▸
"A given reaction always runs in one direction."
A reversible reaction can run either way; the direction depends on the current mixture compared to equilibrium. Starting with excess product, the same reaction runs backward. Direction is set by Q versus K, not fixed.
Fix. Determine direction by comparing Q to K for the current mixture, not by assuming a fixed one-way reaction.
"Q is always equal to K."
Q equals K only at equilibrium. Away from equilibrium, Q differs from K, and that difference is exactly what tells the system which way to shift. Q is a variable; K is a fixed target (at a given temperature).
Fix. Treat Q as changing with the current concentrations; it equals K only when the system is at equilibrium.
"If Q < K, the reaction shifts left."
Q < K means too little product, so the reaction shifts right (toward products) to raise Q up to K. It is Q > K that shifts left. Mixing up the two reverses every direction prediction.
Fix. Use: Q < K → shift right (make product); Q > K → shift left (make reactant).
§6
Skill Check.
▸
Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.