Mistake Master
Displacement, velocity, and acceleration
Position, velocity, and acceleration are three different things, not three names for the same number. Position says where. Velocity says how fast position is changing. Acceleration says how fast velocity is changing. Most points lost on Topic 1.2 problems trace back to treating velocity and acceleration as if they were two ways of writing the same number. They are not.
§1
What this topic is about.
▸
Position, velocity, and acceleration are three different things; each is the rate of change of the one before it. A car at rest has $v = 0$ but can have large $a$ the instant the driver hits the gas; a car cruising at $30$ m/s has large $v$ but $a = 0$. The number for one tells you nothing about the number for the other.
§2
Displacement: change in position.
▸
Pick a positive direction (call it east) once and use it for the whole problem. Displacement is the change in position from start to end:
$$\Delta x = x_f - x_i.$$The signs are not optional. If $x_i = -3$ m and $x_f = +5$ m, then $\Delta x = (+5) - (-3) = +8$ m. The displacement is $+8$ m east. Subtract a negative; do not skip the parentheses.
Displacement is not distance. Distance is total path length: always positive, accumulates over every segment regardless of direction.
The two agree when motion never reverses and part company the moment it does. A jogger who runs one full $400$ m lap and stops at the start has distance $400$ m and displacement $0$ m.
§3
Average velocity.
▸
Average velocity is the displacement divided by the time interval over which it happened:
$$\bar v = \dfrac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{x_f - x_i}{\Delta t}.$$The numerator is displacement (signed); the denominator $\Delta t$ is always positive. So the sign of $\bar v$ comes entirely from $\Delta x$. It tells you which side of the start the object ended up on.
Worked example. A car drives $20$ m east in $4$ s, sits at rest for $2$ s, then drives $10$ m west in $4$ s. East is positive. Total time is $\Delta t = 4 + 2 + 4 = 10$ s. Net displacement is $\Delta x = (+20) + 0 + (-10) = +10$ m east.
$$\bar v = \dfrac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{+10 \text{ m}}{10 \text{ s}} = +1 \text{ m/s}.$$So $\bar v = +1$ m/s east. This is not the speed at any instant (the car was at $+5$, $0$, then about $-2.5$ m/s on the three legs). "Average" here means net displacement over total time.
Compare against average speed, which uses path length, not displacement:
$$\text{average speed} = \dfrac{\text{total distance}}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{20 + 0 + 10}{10} = 3 \text{ m/s}.$$Average speed and $|\bar v|$ are different ($3$ vs $1$ m/s) because the reversal cancelled part of leg one's displacement but added to its distance. Whenever the path reverses, $|\bar v| < $ (average speed), and AP problems exploit that gap.
§4
Average acceleration.
▸
The same shape, one level up. Average acceleration is the change in velocity divided by the time interval:
$$\bar a = \dfrac{\Delta v}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{v_f - v_i}{\Delta t}.$$Final minus initial, signs preserved. Acceleration is to velocity what velocity is to position.
Worked example. A car is travelling east at $v_i = +12$ m/s. The driver brakes uniformly and the car slows to a stop ($v_f = 0$) in $\Delta t = 4$ s. East is positive.
$$\Delta v = v_f - v_i = 0 - (+12) = -12 \text{ m/s}.$$ $$\bar a = \dfrac{\Delta v}{\Delta t} = \dfrac{-12 \text{ m/s}}{4 \text{ s}} = -3 \text{ m/s}^2.$$So $\bar a = -3$ m/s$^2$, that is, $3$ m/s$^2$ west. The car moves east, the acceleration points west: that's what slowing down looks like in 1D.
Same way → speeding up. Opposite ways → slowing down. The sign of $\bar a$ is its direction, not the answer to "speeding or slowing." That depends on the signs of $\vec v$ and $\vec a$ together.
§5
Accelerating without speeding up.
▸
An object is accelerating whenever $\vec v$ is changing: magnitude, direction, or both. Three cases catch most students out, none of them "speeding up" in the everyday sense.
Reversing at the same speed. A ball going east at $+4$ m/s bounces off a wall and returns west at $-4$ m/s. Speed unchanged, but $\Delta v = (-4) - (+4) = -8$ m/s. Over a short contact time, $\bar a$ is large and points west.
$v = 0$ during constant deceleration. A cart at $+6$ m/s with $\bar a = -3$ m/s$^2$ passes through $v = 0$ at $t = 2$ s. At that instant the acceleration is still $-3$ m/s$^2$; whatever's decelerating the cart doesn't pause at the turnaround. Treating $v = 0$ as $a = 0$ is one of the most common errors on this topic.
Turning at constant speed. A car rounding a bend at a steady $30$ mph has constant speed but changing direction of $\vec v$. It is accelerating, with $\vec a$ pointing toward the inside of the curve (size computed in Topic 1.5).
Accelerating does not always mean getting faster, and $v = 0$ does not mean $a = 0$.
§6
Three mistakes that cost real points.
▸
Three failure modes that collapse distinctions the test measures separately.
"Distance and displacement are essentially the same thing."
They are not. Distance is total path length (always positive, accumulates). Displacement is net change in position (signed; depends only on start and end). They agree on a straight east-only walk and diverge the moment motion reverses: a $400$ m lap has distance $400$ m, displacement $0$ m. Position isn't displacement either. Position is where you are, displacement is how far you've moved from the start.
Fix. "Displacement" → $x_f - x_i$ with signs. "Distance" → add path lengths regardless of direction. When in doubt, write both.
"$-15$ m/s is a smaller velocity than $+8$ m/s."
A negative sign is a direction, not a discount. A skater going west at $-15$ m/s has a larger speed than one going east at $+8$ m/s. Reading "more negative" as "smaller" causes about half the mistakes on this topic.
Fix. Read the sign as direction, then compare magnitudes for size questions. Subtract with parentheses every time: $(-8) - (+12) = -20$.
"If something is moving forward, its acceleration must point forward too."
$\vec v$ and $\vec a$ are independent. A car moving east with $\vec a$ west is slowing down. A ball at the peak of a toss has $v = 0$ and $\vec a \neq 0$ (gravity doesn't pause). A bouncing ball has equal before/after speeds but huge $\vec a$ during contact. Treating "direction the object is moving" as the direction of $\vec a$ is the single most expensive mistake on Topic 1.2.
Fix. Compute $\bar a = (v_f - v_i)/\Delta t$ with signs. The sign of the result is the direction of $\bar a$. Speeding vs slowing depends on whether $\vec v$ and $\vec a$ point the same way (speeding) or opposite (slowing).
Ten scenarios in 1D motion (east positive): three on distance/position/displacement, two on sign discipline, five on the velocity-vs-acceleration distinction. Pick magnitude (and direction where it applies), then check.
01 / 10Displacement on a back-and-forth path
A walker walks $8$ m east, then $5$ m back west, all along the same straight road. East is positive. What is the walker's displacement?
02 / 10Displacement on a closed loop
A jogger runs one full lap around a $400$ m oval track and stops at the same starting line where she began. What is the magnitude of her displacement? (Magnitude has no direction, so just pick a number.)
03 / 10Displacement across the origin
A robot's position changes from $x_i = -4$ m to $x_f = +6$ m. East is the positive direction. What is the robot's displacement?
04 / 10Change in speed when speed grows in the negative direction
A skater glides west at $v_i = -10$ m/s. After a push from behind, his velocity becomes $v_f = -16$ m/s. East is positive. What is the magnitude of the change in his speed? (Speed is a scalar, so this answer has no direction.)
05 / 10Average acceleration when velocity reverses
A toy car's velocity changes from $v_i = +12$ m/s east to $v_f = -8$ m/s west over $\Delta t = 4$ s. East is the positive direction. What is the car's average acceleration over the interval?
06 / 10Speed after $2$ s with same-sign $v$ and $a$
A puck moving on a frictionless ice rink has velocity $v_0 = -3$ m/s and acceleration $a = -4$ m/s$^2$ (constant) along the same line. East is positive. After $2$ seconds, what is the puck's speed? (Speed is a scalar, so this answer has no direction.)
07 / 10Average acceleration of a truck slowing to a stop
A truck moving east at $18$ m/s comes to a complete stop in $\Delta t = 6$ s, decelerating uniformly. East is positive. What is the truck's average acceleration over the interval?
08 / 10Acceleration at the instant $v = 0$
A cart moving east decelerates uniformly at a constant rate, with $\bar a = -3$ m/s$^2$ in the east-positive convention. At the exact instant when the cart's velocity is zero (the turnaround), what is the cart's acceleration?
09 / 10Average acceleration during a bounce
A ball's velocity changes from $v_i = +4$ m/s east to $v_f = -4$ m/s west over a $\Delta t = 2$ s interval (a slow bounce off a soft wall). East is positive. What is the ball's average acceleration during the bounce?
10 / 10Average acceleration vs average velocity
A cart's velocity changes uniformly from $v_i = +10$ m/s to $v_f = +2$ m/s over $\Delta t = 4$ s. East is the positive direction. What is the cart's average acceleration over the interval?