Mistake Master
Angular momentum and angular impulse
Angular momentum is the rotational partner of linear momentum: $\vec{L}=\vec{r}\times\vec{p}$ for a particle, and $L=I\omega$ for a rigid body spinning about a fixed axis. A torque acting over time delivers an angular impulse, $\int\tau\,dt$, which equals the change in angular momentum: $\Delta L=\int\tau\,dt$, the area under the torque-versus-time graph. This is the time partner of Topic 6.2, where a torque acting over an angle did work. The five mistakes here are bookkeeping slips about which quantity changes and what sign it carries, not new ideas.
§1
What this topic is about
▸
A spinning body carries angular momentum, the rotational version of linear momentum. For a particle it is $\vec{L}=\vec{r}\times\vec{p}$; for a rigid body about a fixed axis it is $L=I\omega$, the moment of inertia times the angular speed. It is a vector, with a direction set by the right-hand rule.
A torque changes that angular momentum. Over a time interval it delivers an angular impulse, $\int\tau\,dt$, which equals the change $\Delta L$. This is the rotational twin of the linear impulse $\int F\,dt=\Delta p$, and the time partner of Topic 6.2: there a torque acting over an angle did work; here a torque acting over time changes angular momentum.
Five habits carry the topic: integrate when $\tau$ varies in time, tell angular impulse apart from work, pair the moment of inertia with the angular speed, keep the $\sin\theta$ in the cross product, and find the direction with the right-hand rule.
§2
Angular momentum: $\vec{L}=\vec{r}\times\vec{p}=I\omega$
▸
Angular momentum comes in two equivalent forms. For a single particle, $\vec{L}=\vec{r}\times\vec{p}$, where $\vec{r}$ is the position from the reference point and $\vec{p}=m\vec{v}$ is the linear momentum. Its magnitude is $L=rp\sin\theta=rmv\sin\theta$, with $\theta$ the angle between $\vec{r}$ and $\vec{p}$.
For a rigid body spinning about a fixed axis, the particle pieces add up to $L=I\omega$: the moment of inertia times the angular speed. This is the rotational partner of $p=mv$, with $I$ standing in for mass and $\omega$ for velocity.
- $\vec{L}=\vec{r}\times\vec{p}$, magnitude $rmv\sin\theta$, for a particle.
- $L=I\omega$, for a rigid body about a fixed axis.
The partners must match. Using $mv$ alone gives linear momentum, not angular; using $M$ with $\omega$ or $I$ with a rim speed $v$ mixes a linear quantity with a rotational one. Match $I$ with $\omega$, and keep the lever arm $r$ for a particle.
Angular momentum is $\vec{L}=\vec{r}\times\vec{p}$ (magnitude $rmv\sin\theta$) for a particle, and $L=I\omega$ for a rigid body. Match $I$ with $\omega$; $mv$ on its own is linear momentum.
§3
Angular impulse: $\Delta L=\int\tau\,dt$
▸
A torque acting over time changes angular momentum. For a constant torque the change is $\Delta L=\tau\,\Delta t$: torque times the time, in $\mathrm{kg\cdot m^2/s}$. It is the rotational version of the linear impulse $\Delta p=F\,\Delta t$.
When the torque varies with time, cut the interval into tiny steps $dt$. Over each step the torque adds $dL=\tau\,dt$. Adding the steps gives the angular impulse, the area under the torque-versus-time curve:
- $\Delta L=\displaystyle\int_{t_1}^{t_2}\tau\,dt$, the area under the $\tau$-versus-$t$ curve between the start and end times.
For example, $\tau(t)=6t$ N$\cdot$m from $t=0$ to $t=2$ s delivers $\Delta L=\int_0^2 6t\,dt=3t^2\big|_0^2=12\ \mathrm{kg\cdot m^2/s}$: the triangle under the line, not $\tau\,\Delta t$.
Angular impulse is the area under the $\tau$-versus-$t$ curve, $\Delta L=\int\tau\,dt$. For a constant torque that area is the rectangle $\tau\,\Delta t$; for a varying torque, integrate.
§4
Angular impulse versus work
▸
The same torque can be integrated two ways, giving two different quantities. Integrate over time and you get the angular impulse, $\int\tau\,dt=\Delta L$, the change in angular momentum, in $\mathrm{kg\cdot m^2/s}$. Integrate over angle and you get the work, $\int\tau\,d\theta=\Delta K$, the change in rotational kinetic energy, in joules.
Mixing them up is the common slip: giving $\tau\,\Delta\theta$ (work) when the impulse is wanted, or $\tau\,\Delta t$ (impulse) when the work is wanted. The power $P=\tau\omega$, a per-second rate in watts, is a third quantity. For a constant $\tau=8$ N$\cdot$m over $\Delta t=2$ s while the wheel turns $\Delta\theta=10$ rad, the impulse is $\tau\,\Delta t=16\ \mathrm{kg\cdot m^2/s}$ but the work is $\tau\,\Delta\theta=80$ J: different numbers, different units, different physics.
Time gives impulse: $\int\tau\,dt=\Delta L$ ($\mathrm{kg\cdot m^2/s}$). Angle gives work: $\int\tau\,d\theta=\Delta K$ (joules). Check which variable you integrate over.
§5
The cross product: magnitude and direction
▸
For a particle, angular momentum is a cross product, so it has a magnitude and a direction. The magnitude is $L=rp\sin\theta=rmv\sin\theta$, where $r\sin\theta$ is the perpendicular lever arm, the shortest distance from the reference point to the line of motion. The $\sin\theta$ is not optional: dropping it (writing $rp$) assumes the motion is already perpendicular, and using $\cos\theta$ takes the wrong component.
The direction comes from the right-hand rule for $\vec{r}\times\vec{p}$: point the fingers along $\vec{r}$, curl them toward $\vec{p}$, and the thumb gives $\vec{L}$, perpendicular to both. For motion in a plane, $\vec{L}$ points out of the page or into it. It is not along $\vec{r}$ and not along $\vec{p}$, and reversing the order ($\vec{p}\times\vec{r}$) flips the sign. Once you pick the original spin direction as positive, a braking torque opposes the spin, so it delivers a negative $\Delta L$ that you subtract.
For $\vec{r}=3\hat{\imath}$ m and $\vec{p}=4\hat{\jmath}$ kg$\cdot$m/s, $\vec{L}=(3)(4)(\hat{\imath}\times\hat{\jmath})=12\hat{k}\ \mathrm{kg\cdot m^2/s}$: magnitude $12$, pointing out of the page.
Magnitude $L=rmv\sin\theta$ uses the perpendicular lever arm; direction comes from the right-hand rule for $\vec{r}\times\vec{p}$, perpendicular to both. Keep the $\sin\theta$ and keep the sign.
§6
Five mistakes that cost real points
▸
Angular-momentum problems tend to break at the same joints: mixing up angular impulse with rotational work, pairing the wrong factors, or dropping the $\sin\theta$ and the direction.
- Constant-torque shortcutUsing $\tau\,\Delta t$ when $\tau$ varies in time. Fix: integrate, $\Delta L=\int\tau\,dt$.
- Impulse vs workIntegrating torque over angle (work) when the impulse is wanted, or over time when work is wanted. Fix: time gives $\Delta L$, angle gives work.
- Mismatched partnersUsing $mv$, $M\omega$, or $Iv$ for angular momentum. Fix: $L=I\omega$ for a body, $rmv\sin\theta$ for a particle.
- Missing sineWriting $rp$ or $rp\cos\theta$ for the cross-product magnitude. Fix: $L=rp\sin\theta$, the perpendicular component.
- Direction and signTreating $\vec{L}$ as a scalar, or dropping the sign of a braking $\Delta L$. Fix: right-hand rule for direction, keep the sign.
Integrate when $\tau$ varies, tell impulse from work, match $I$ with $\omega$, keep the $\sin\theta$, and find the direction with the right-hand rule. The whole topic comes down to those five habits.
Skill check
Ten scenarios across the five Topic 6.3 mistakes. Each gives a situation and four answers; pick one before checking to see where the traps are. Progress is saved.