Mistake Master
Free energy of dissolution
Why does a cold pack get cold as it dissolves — absorbing heat — yet dissolve anyway? Because dissolving is a free-energy decision, and entropy can outvote an unfavorable enthalpy.
§1
Dissolution as a free-energy balance.
▸
Whether a substance dissolves is a free-energy question: ΔG = ΔH − TΔS for the dissolution. It dissolves spontaneously when ΔG < 0.
The solution enthalpy (ΔH) is the sum of two opposing pieces: the endothermic cost of separating the lattice (breaking ion-ion attractions) and the exothermic release from hydrating the ions (attracting them to water).
Because entropy usually rises when an ordered lattice disperses into solution, an endothermic dissolution can still be favorable: if TΔS is large enough, ΔG is negative even though ΔH > 0.
§2
Weighing the terms.
▸
Build ΔH from its parts, then weigh against TΔS.
- Separate the lattice. Breaking the ionic lattice costs energy — this part is endothermic.
- Hydrate the ions. Surrounding ions with water releases energy — this part is exothermic.
- Get the solution enthalpy. ΔH_solution = lattice cost + hydration release (net sign depends on their sizes).
- Compare with entropy. Even if ΔH > 0, a large TΔS can make ΔG < 0 — it still dissolves.
§3
The pieces you'll meet.
▸
The pieces of dissolving.
§4
Worked example: an endothermic dissolution that happens.
▸
Observation. A salt dissolves while the solution gets colder — it absorbs heat, so ΔH_solution > 0 (endothermic).
Enthalpy parts. The endothermic lattice-separation cost slightly exceeds the exothermic hydration release, so the net ΔH is positive.
Entropy. The ordered lattice disperses into freely moving hydrated ions, so ΔS > 0 and TΔS is a positive, favorable term.
Verdict. ΔG = ΔH − TΔS can be negative because TΔS outweighs the positive ΔH — the salt dissolves despite being endothermic.
§5
Mistakes that cost real points.
▸
"Separating the ionic lattice releases energy."
Breaking the lattice pulls oppositely charged ions apart against their attraction, which costs energy — it is endothermic. Only the hydration step (attracting ions to water) releases energy. Treating lattice separation as exothermic mis-signs the solution enthalpy.
Fix. Count lattice separation as an endothermic cost and hydration as the exothermic release.
"An endothermic dissolution is impossible."
Many salts dissolve endothermically. Dissolution is governed by ΔG = ΔH − TΔS, so a favorable entropy increase (dispersing the lattice) can make ΔG negative even when ΔH > 0. Endothermic dissolving is common (cold packs).
Fix. Judge dissolving by ΔG, not ΔH alone; entropy can drive an endothermic dissolution.
"The solution enthalpy is just the hydration energy."
The solution enthalpy is the sum of the endothermic lattice-separation cost and the exothermic hydration release, not hydration alone. Leaving out the lattice term (or the hydration term) gives the wrong net ΔH and the wrong prediction.
Fix. Add both pieces — lattice cost and hydration release — to get the solution enthalpy.
§6
Skill Check.
▸
Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.