Mistake Master
Cell potential, nonstandard
Standard potentials assume a tidy 1 M, 1 atm world. Real cells are messier — and a running battery, or a concentration cell built from one metal, gets its voltage from exactly that departure from standard.
§1
The Nernst equation.
▸
When concentrations differ from standard, the cell potential shifts from E° according to the Nernst equation. At 25 °C, E = E° − (0.05916/n) log Q, where Q is the reaction quotient.
So an operating cell is not pinned to E°: as reactants are consumed, Q rises, and E falls below E°. A concentration cell — the same species at different concentrations on each side — has E° = 0 but a nonzero E, driven entirely by the concentration difference.
The potential reaches zero only at equilibrium (when Q = K). A working cell delivering current is not at equilibrium, so its potential is nonzero.
§2
Applying the Nernst equation.
▸
Shift E° by the Q term.
- Start from E°. The standard potential is the baseline.
- Form Q. The reaction quotient from the actual (nonstandard) concentrations.
- Apply the shift. E = E° − (0.05916/n) log Q at 25 °C; E moves away from E° as Q changes.
- Locate equilibrium. E = 0 only when Q = K; a working cell is not there yet.
§3
The pieces you'll meet.
▸
Nonstandard potentials.
§4
Worked example: shifting from standard.
▸
Setup. A cell has E° = +1.10 V and transfers n = 2 electrons at 25 °C.
Q > 1. If product ions have built up so Q = 10, then log Q = 1 and E = 1.10 − (0.05916/2)(1) = 1.10 − 0.0296 ≈ +1.07 V — slightly below E°.
Concentration cell. If both half-cells used the same couple (E° = 0) with different concentrations, E would be nonzero, set entirely by the −(0.05916/n) log Q term.
Equilibrium. Only when Q reaches K does E fall to 0 and the cell die.
§5
Mistakes that cost real points.
▸
"The cell potential stays at E° regardless of concentration."
Under nonstandard conditions the potential shifts from E° according to the Nernst equation, E = E° − (0.05916/n) log Q. As concentrations change, so does E. Assuming E is fixed at E° ignores how real, operating cells behave.
Fix. Use the Nernst equation: E moves away from E° as Q departs from 1.
"A concentration cell has zero voltage because both sides are the same substance."
A concentration cell has E° = 0 but a nonzero E, because the two half-cells are at different concentrations — the Nernst term drives a real potential. It produces voltage until the concentrations equalize.
Fix. Recognize a concentration cell runs on the concentration difference (E° = 0, E ≠ 0).
"A cell delivering current is already at equilibrium."
A cell that is producing current is away from equilibrium (Q ≠ K); its potential is nonzero. The potential reaches zero only at equilibrium, when the cell is dead. A working cell has not gotten there yet.
Fix. Treat an operating cell as not at equilibrium; E = 0 only when Q = K.
§6
Skill Check.
▸
Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.