Mistake Master
Multistep energy profiles
A multistep reaction's energy profile is a mountain range, not a single hill: one peak per step, a valley for each intermediate. The tallest peak is the bottleneck, and the start-to-finish drop is still the overall ΔH.
§1
Peaks, valleys, and the tallest barrier.
▸
A multistep reaction energy profile shows one barrier (transition state) for each elementary step — so a two-step reaction has two peaks. Between the peaks sits a valley: an intermediate, a real species formed along the way.
The highest barrier corresponds to the slowest, rate-determining step. That tallest peak is the bottleneck that limits the overall rate.
The overall ΔH is still just the difference between the starting reactants and the final products — read from the two ends of the profile, ignoring the peaks and valleys in between.
§2
Reading a multistep profile.
▸
Identify peaks, valleys, the tallest barrier, and the endpoints.
- Count the peaks. One transition state per elementary step; the number of peaks equals the number of steps.
- Find the intermediates. The valleys between peaks are intermediates — real species, unlike the fleeting transition states.
- Locate the tallest barrier. The highest peak is the rate-determining step, the overall bottleneck.
- Read the overall ΔH. Compare the first reactant energy to the final product energy; the in-between features do not change ΔH.
§3
The pieces you'll meet.
▸
Peaks are transition states; valleys are intermediates.
§4
Worked example: a two-step profile.
▸
Profile. Reactants → peak 1 (tall) → valley (intermediate) → peak 2 (shorter) → products, with products below reactants.
Steps. Two peaks mean two elementary steps; the valley between is an intermediate.
Rate-determining step. Peak 1 is taller, so the first step has the higher barrier and is rate-determining.
Overall ΔH. Products sit below reactants, so ΔH < 0 (exothermic) — read from the two ends, independent of the two peaks and the valley.
§5
Mistakes that cost real points.
▸
"The valleys in a multistep profile are transition states."
The valleys are intermediates — real, if short-lived, species that sit at energy minima between steps. The peaks are the transition states. Confusing valleys (intermediates) with peaks (transition states) inverts the picture.
Fix. Read peaks as transition states and valleys as intermediates. Intermediates are minima; transition states are maxima.
"The rate-determining step is the one with the lowest barrier."
The rate-determining step has the highest barrier (tallest peak), not the lowest — it is the hardest step to get over and thus the bottleneck. Picking the lowest peak reverses the logic.
Fix. Identify the rate-determining step as the tallest barrier on the profile.
"The overall ΔH is the height of the biggest barrier."
Overall ΔH is the difference between the initial reactants and the final products, not any barrier height. A profile can have a huge barrier but a small ΔH, or vice versa; the two are unrelated features.
Fix. Read overall ΔH from the two endpoints of the profile; ignore the peaks and valleys in between.
§6
Skill Check.
▸
Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.