Mistake Master
Everything in the picture is a function of time AB & BC
A related rates problem hands you one rate and asks for another. The arithmetic is rarely the difficulty. Almost everything that goes wrong here goes wrong before a single number is substituted: the wrong relationship gets written down, something that is moving gets treated as fixed, or the chain rule quietly fails to happen.
§1
Two quantities, one relationship, both moving.
▸
A related rates problem always has the same shape. Two or more quantities are tied together by a geometric or algebraic relationship, and all of them are changing as time passes. Differentiating the relationship with respect to $t$ produces an equation relating their rates.
The one habit that makes the rest work: write every varying quantity as a function of time, out loud, before differentiating. A circle's area and radius are not $A$ and $r$; they are $A(t)$ and $r(t)$, tied by
$$A(t) = \pi\left[r(t)\right]^{2}.$$
Written that way, differentiating both sides with respect to $t$ is just the chain rule from Topic 3.1:
$$\frac{dA}{dt} = 2\pi r \frac{dr}{dt}.$$
The factor $\frac{dr}{dt}$ is not decoration. It is the derivative of the inside function, and dropping it produces $\frac{dA}{dt} = 2\pi r$, which is not even dimensionally sensible: the left side is an area per unit time and the right side is a length.
§2
Every varying letter picks up its own rate.
▸
The rule generalizes with no exceptions. Differentiating with respect to $t$:
- $V = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^{3} \;\Rightarrow\; \dfrac{dV}{dt} = 4\pi r^{2}\dfrac{dr}{dt}$.
- $x^{2} + y^{2} = 169 \;\Rightarrow\; 2x\dfrac{dx}{dt} + 2y\dfrac{dy}{dt} = 0$.
- $xy = 12 \;\Rightarrow\; \dfrac{dx}{dt}\,y + x\dfrac{dy}{dt} = 0$, by the product rule, since both factors move.
When a relationship holds three varying quantities, all three rate factors appear. For a cylinder whose radius and height both change,
$$V = \pi r^{2}h \;\Rightarrow\; \frac{dV}{dt} = \pi\left(2r\frac{dr}{dt}h + r^{2}\frac{dh}{dt}\right),$$
which is the product rule applied to $r^2 \cdot h$, with a chain-rule factor on each. Attaching $\frac{dr}{dt}$ to one term and forgetting $\frac{dh}{dt}$ on the other is the most common way this goes wrong, and it silently assumes the height is frozen.
A genuine constant, by contrast, contributes nothing. A ladder's length really is fixed, so in $x^2 + y^2 = 169$ the right side differentiates to 0.
§3
Which quantities are actually constant.
▸
Deciding what is fixed and what is moving is a modeling question, and it is worth spending real time on. Two categories that get confused:
- Genuinely constant: the length of a rigid ladder, the full dimensions of a tank, the height of a lamppost, the fixed 15 miles per hour of a car described as travelling at a constant speed.
- Only momentarily equal to a number: the water's depth in the tank right now, the radius of the oil slick at this instant, the distance between two cars at 2 pm.
Anything in the second group is a function of $t$ that happens to have a known value at one moment. It carries a rate factor and it must not be replaced by its number before the differentiation. Topic 4.5 makes that trap explicit; here it is enough to notice which letters belong in which group.
The constraint is the other half of this. A cone-shaped tank whose full radius is 4 and full height 12 forces the water's surface radius and depth to satisfy $\frac{r}{h} = \frac{4}{12} = \frac{1}{3}$ at every instant, by similar triangles. Using it to write $r = \frac{h}{3}$ turns a two-variable relationship into one variable:
$$V = \frac{1}{3}\pi r^{2}h = \frac{1}{3}\pi\left(\frac{h}{3}\right)^{2}h = \frac{\pi h^{3}}{27}.$$
Now only $\frac{dh}{dt}$ appears. Skipping the constraint leaves an equation with two unknown rates and one equation, which cannot be solved.
§4
The setup, as a checklist.
▸
Five steps, and the last one is where 4.5 picks up.
- Draw it, and label every length with a letter, not a number, if it is changing.
- Name the rates. Which derivative is given, and which is wanted? Write both down in $\frac{d\,?}{dt}$ form with their signs: something shrinking gets a minus.
- Find the relationship tying the two quantities together. Similar triangles, the Pythagorean relation, a volume or area formula, or a stated model.
- Use any constraint to eliminate variables you have no rate for.
- Differentiate both sides with respect to $t$, attaching a rate factor to every varying letter. Only then substitute the instant's numbers.
Step 2 deserves the extra half minute. A great many wrong answers are a correctly solved problem that answered for $\frac{dx}{dt}$ when $\frac{dy}{dt}$ was asked for, or that treated the given rate as the unknown.
§5
Skill Check.
▸
Ten scenarios. Pick the chips that match your answer, then check. A scenario marks complete the first time every part is right. Progress saves on this device.