Mistake Master
Student view — seeing the site as a student does
Mistake Master · AP Statistics · Unit 3 · Step-Through Animation

An Interval That Contains Zero Has Not Shown the Groups Are Equal

You'll learnto read a direction off a difference interval by locating the WHOLE interval against zero — why an interval containing zero is a failure to decide rather than a finding of equality, why "most of it is positive" measures nothing, why the order of subtraction has to be stated, and how the confidence level can change the answer.

A confidence interval for the difference between two proportions answers one question: is the whole interval on one side of zero? Two checkout systems give (0.018, 0.182) — every value in it is positive, so the new system really does finish more shoppers. Two lecture sections give (−0.022, 0.092), which contains zero, and that is a failure to decide rather than a finding that the sections are equal; 81% of that interval is positive, and 81% establishes nothing at all. A third study runs entirely below zero, and reversing the order of subtraction mirrors it through zero without changing a single fact — which is why a report has to say which group was subtracted from which. And the same checkout data at 99% confidence give (−0.007, 0.207), which contains zero: a stricter standard costs the conclusion. Twelve short steps; press Next for each one.

12 STEPS · 6 QUICK CHECKS · WHOLE INTERVAL vs ZERO · ORDER OF SUBTRACTION · THE LEVEL · v2

One question does all the work: is the whole bar on one side of zero?
Before you start
What you're looking at
One axis of differences between two proportions, a dashed line at zero, and horizontal bars: each bar is a confidence interval for one study's gap.
The question
Is the whole bar on one side of the dashed line? That is the entire reading — and three of the four ways to get it wrong are drawn here.
Step 1 / 12