Mistake Master
Student view — seeing the site as a student does
Mistake Master · AP Statistics · Unit 3 · Step-Through Animation

An Interval That Contains Zero Has Not Shown the Groups Are Equal

You'll learnhow to judge a claim about two population proportions from a confidence interval for their difference: what entirely above or below zero establishes, why containing zero is a failure to decide rather than a finding of equality, and why the sign of the endpoints means nothing until the order of subtraction is written down.

For a difference of two proportions, one value carries all the weight: zero, the claim that the two population proportions are equal. This page builds three intervals from their raw counts and holds each against the same dashed line. A checkout study's interval lands entirely above zero, so a direction is established and a magnitude comes with it. A second study's interval straddles zero — and 81% of its length is positive, which decides exactly nothing, because a negative difference is still inside. A third study's interval sits entirely below zero, until the order of subtraction is reversed and the same finding prints with both signs flipped. And the first study is run once more at 99% confidence, where the same data produce a wider interval that zero has crept into: the direction was real at one standard of evidence and unavailable at a stricter one.

8 STEPS · 6 QUICK CHECKS · ZERO AS THE NO-DIFFERENCE VALUE · DIRECTION AND ORDER · CONFIDENCE LEVEL · v1

entirely above 0 decides · containing 0 does not · the sign needs the stated order
Before you start
What you're looking at
A number line for the difference between two population proportions, with a dashed line at zero — the value that says the two groups are equal.
The question
A confidence interval for a difference is a range of plausible values. Which claims does its position relative to zero justify, and which does it not?
Watch for
Where each interval sits against the dashed line. Every conclusion this topic allows is read off that one comparison — and every misreading ignores it.
Step 1 / 8